top of page

Alternatives for butter when baking this holiday

“Get ready, set, bake!” This is my favorite line from the highly acclaimed TV series, The Great British Bake Off. When these TV shows inspire you to dust off your pie pan or other favorite baking dish, keep in mind fat is the most integral baking ingredient. Grandma used lard, but today there are many traditional – as well as alternative options – on the market. So what are the best butter alternatives for baking? What healthy fats can be substituted for butter? And when should you use them? Let’s take a look.


1. Ghee as a Butter Alternative for High Heat Baking or Cooking

Ghee is a favorite among those who need to maintain a lactose and casein free diet. It’s made from butter but the milk solids, water and impurities have been removed. This is a good substitute for traditional butter in all types of cooking. It has a high smoke point which means you can use it to fry, sauté, or bake. The other benefit is that it is loaded with nutrients, specifically, fatty acids like omegas 3 and 9, fat soluble vitamins (A, D, E and K) as well as butyric acid. Butyric acid supports the health of the intestinal cells.


my pick and runner up for alternative to butter, ghee

Here is the type of ghee that I keep in my pantry: Ancient Organics 100% Organic Ghee.


A close runner up is: Organic Valley Organic Ghee.


Note: Both of these brands provide a subtle nutty flavor that blends well with any ingredient or cooking application.


2. Coconut Oil’s Low Temperature Fat Best Used for Sweet Treats

Coconut oil has evolved as a go-to for all things health related. Books have been written about this single ingredient as a cure all. While I may not use it in all its touted applications, I definitely incorporate it into my daily cooking routine. Coconut oil is an acquired taste. I find that its natural flavor is best for baking. The natural sweetness of desserts compliments the aroma and flavor of this fat. This is important because my preferred type of coconut oil has the most intense aroma and flavor compared to its processed counterparts.


It may be overwhelming to select a coconut oil due to the wide array of options on the grocery store shelf. It is best to stick to unrefined or virgin coconut oils because this limits the use of chemicals and other additives in the production process. If refined coconut oil is the only option, purchase an organic variety to limit contaminants. Unlike ghee, unrefined coconut oil is best used in lower temperature cooking conditions under 350º F. Most baking recipes meet this standard. Unlike other fats, extra virgin and virgin are the same when it comes to coconut oil. Organic versus non-organic is not a necessary classification for the unrefined brands because the pesticides do not impact the meat of the coconut. If you’re purchasing ready to eat foods, avoid hydrogenated forms of coconut oil. This type of coconut oil includes trans fats.


my pick and runner up for alternative to butter, coconut oil

Here is the type of coconut oil that I keep in my pantry: Dr. Bonner’s Coconut Oil.


A close runner up is: Nutiva Organic Virgin Coconut Oil.


3. Avocado Oil’s Mild Flavor Works Well as a Butter Alternative

Avocado oil is often compared to olive oil because of its similar fat content of monounsaturated fats. These are the heart healthy fats. Unlike olive oil, this type of fat has a significantly higher smoke point of 520º F. This makes it a good fat source for grilling. However, it can also be used as a butter alternative in baking. I like to use it in baked dishes that benefit from a milder flavor fat. For example, chocolate pairs well with the strong flavor of coconut oil while a bread or cake may benefit from the less intense flavor of avocado oil. And, you can feel good about the anti-inflammatory benefits of this fat while indulging in a sweet treat.


my pick and runner up for alternative to butter, avocadooil

Here is the type of avocado oil that I keep in my pantry: Primal Kitchen California Extra Virgin Avocado Oil.


4. Olive Oil Can Be Your Go-To for Baking Bread

Biscotti, anyone? Olive oil is usually associated with salad dressings and other sauces. However, olive oil can also be used in baking. It can be substituted for any other liquid fat like a vegetable oil. Bread recipes are your best bet when using olive oil. Have you ever heard of lemon olive oil cake? This classic recipe is the perfect example of how this fat can produce a satisfying and healthy dessert. Before you jump into using olive oil as your baking fat, let’s make sure you choose the right type of olive oil. The key is to purchase an extra virgin olive oil. This variety will bake well up until 375º-420º F and is less refined than other olive oils. It is rich in polyphenols and has a multitude of anti-inflammatory benefits. To make sure that the olive oil will maintain its nutrient density, purchase olive oil in dark containers and store in a cool, dark place.


my pick and runner up for alternative to butter, olive oil

Here is the type of olive oil that I keep in my pantry: California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil.


My latest baking find is: Claudio Vignoli Extra Virgin Olive Oil.


Note: If you purchase extra virgin olive oil in plastic containers, I recommend transitioning them to dark glass containers.


Final Words on Choosing Healthy Butter Alternatives for Baking or Cooking

No matter the type of fats you choose as your go-to butter alternatives for baking or cooking, it is important to comply with the type of fat recommended for the recipe. For example, if it calls for a solid fat, use a fat that is solid at room temperature (i.e. ghee or coconut oil). If it calls for a liquid fat, use a fat that is liquid at room temperature (i.e. olive oil, avocado oil, sesame oil). This will effect the ultimate function of the fat which is to provide moisture, flavor and favorable texture to the dessert.


If you need assistance finding healthy alternatives for improved health and lifestyle, contact me.

 

This article was guest-written by:

Headshot of Emily Luxford, registered dietitian
Emily Luxford, MS, RD, IFNCP, CLT

Emily Luxford is a functional dietitian nutritionist helping patients navigate gut health, diabetes, obesity, malabsorption disorders, and autoimmune diseases, along with complex illnesses such as immune dysfunction syndromes, myofascial pain, depression, vertigo, headaches, and cancer. Learn more about her and her services at www.luxfordnutrition.com.

bottom of page